top of page
Prime Video Games Logo

Where to Sell Video Games in Charlotte, NC

2 days ago
4 min read

Got a shelf of games you don't play anymore? You're not alone. Whether it's a stack of PS4 discs, a box of N64 cartridges from your childhood, or a whole collection you've outgrown, those games are worth real money to someone.


If you live in Charlotte, Indian Trail, Matthews, Monroe or anywhere nearby, you have more options than you might think. Some will pay you a fair price. Others will hand you a few dollars in store credit and resell your games for many times that.


This guide walks through your choices, which games are worth the most, and how to get top dollar for your collection.


A stack of used Xbox 360 and PlayStation 2 games bought by Prime Video Games

Your options for selling games around Charlotte


  • Big-box trade-in chains. Fast and easy, but mostly store credit, and cash offers are usually lower. Best for swapping a few recent games for new ones.


  • Online marketplaces (eBay, Mercari). Close to full market value, minus selling and payment fees. But you'll spend days to weeks on photos, listings, buyer questions and packing. Best for rare or high-value single games.


  • Facebook Marketplace and local groups. Cash, but buyers often haggle hard, and you deal with messages, no-shows and meeting strangers.


  • A local game shop like Prime Video Games. A fair offer based on current market value within 24–48 hours, with local meetups or shipping. Best for collections, retro games, and anyone who wants it done fairly and fast.


Trade-in chains are convenient, but they're built around store credit, and their cash prices for older games are often a small fraction of what those games sell for. Marketplaces pay more but turn selling into a part-time job.


A local shop that specializes in games sits in the middle. You get a price based on what your games are actually worth, without having to list them one by one.



Which games are worth the most


Values change all the time, but some things consistently bring higher offers:


  • Nintendo games of any era. First-party Nintendo titles hold their value better than almost anything else, from NES and Super Nintendo cartridges to GameCube and Switch.


  • Pokémon games. Especially the Game Boy, GBA and DS titles, which are always in demand.


  • Complete in box. A game with its original case, manual and inserts is often worth much more than the cartridge or disc alone.


  • Short print runs. RPGs and niche titles that didn't sell many copies the first time around are often the hidden gems in a collection.


  • Consoles and controllers. Working retro consoles and official controllers are worth more than most people expect.


Not sure what you have? Look up any title on PriceCharting, the price guide we use for our offers, or just send us your list.



How to get the best price


  1. Find all the pieces. Gather the cases, manuals and inserts. Complete games get higher offers.


  2. Clean them gently. Wipe off dust and sticky residue. Don't scrub labels or use harsh chemicals on cartridges.


  3. Test everything. Make sure your games and consoles work before you sell.


  4. Make a simple list. Write the title, the system, and whether it's complete. Photos of the whole collection help too.


  5. Sell as a bundle. One buyer for the whole collection is faster and usually gets you a better overall price than selling game by game.


  6. Compare offers. Know roughly what your best few games sell for, so you can spot a lowball offer.



Selling to Prime Video Games


Prime Video Games is a locally owned game shop in Indian Trail, NC. We buy from players and collectors across the Charlotte area with local meetups, and from anywhere in the U.S. by mail.


We buy: PlayStation (PS1 through PS5, PSP, PS Vita), Xbox (original through Series X|S), Nintendo (NES through Switch, plus Game Boy, GBA, DS and 3DS), Sega (Genesis, Saturn, Dreamcast), consoles, controllers and accessories, plus trading cards: Pokémon, One Piece, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh! and Disney Lorcana.


Here's how it works:


  1. Send us your list on our Sell Your Games page.


  2. Get a free offer within 24–48 hours. It's based on current market value from PriceCharting, so you can see exactly where our numbers come from.


  3. Meet up or ship. Around Charlotte, we can meet up locally. Anywhere else, accept your offer and send us your box size and weight. For offers over $35, we email you a free prepaid shipping label.


  4. Get paid. By PayPal within 24 hours of receiving your games.


No pressure and no obligation. If the offer doesn't work for you, you've lost nothing.



Questions? Call or text us at (980) 710-7979.



FAQ


Do you buy broken games or consoles? No. We only buy games, consoles and accessories that work.


Do you buy loose cartridges and discs without cases? Yes. Complete games get higher offers, but loose games still have value, especially on retro systems.


Do I have to live in Charlotte to sell to you? No. Around Charlotte we meet up locally, and you can ship to us from anywhere in the U.S.


How do you decide what to pay? Our offers are based on current market prices from PriceCharting, so they follow what games are really selling for.


Do I pay for shipping? Not on collections with offers over $35. Once you accept, we email you a free prepaid shipping label and a quick guide to packing your games safely.


How fast do I get paid? We pay by PayPal within 24 hours of receiving your games.


Do you buy trading cards? Yes. We buy Pokémon, One Piece, Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh! and Disney Lorcana cards.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page